Monday, July 16, 2012

a G0Dless world means a meaningless one -by -Dennis Prager in the JewishWorldReview.com

a G0Dless world means a meaningless one

" In fact, no scientific discovery that will ever be made will explain why there is existence, render good and evil anything more than subjective opinion, or explain why human beings have consciousness or anything else that truly matters.

The only thing that can explain existence and answer these other questions is G0D or some other similar metaphysical belief. This angers those scientists and others who are emotionally as well as intellectually committed to atheism. But many honest atheists recognize that a G0Dless world means a meaningless one, and admit that science can only explain what, not why."
-Dennis Prager in the JewishWorldReview.com

Finding Love and Peace in Our Battle against evil -By Rabbi David Aaron

How odd that a violent act of killing would be rewarded

http://www.JewishWorldReview.com | The Israelites were seduced by the Moabite women to serve the idol of Peor. When Zimri, the prince of the Shimonite tribe, publicly takes the princess of Midian to be with her sexually, Pinchas, the grandson of Aaron, kills them both and thereby stops the plague against the people. For this zealous act G-d rewards him with a covenant of peace.


How odd that a violent act of killing would be rewarded with a covenant of peace. Here, however, lies the secret to how much love and peace there should be at the core of a true battle against evil.


“ And as for the slanderers, may they not have hope and may all the evilness in one moment be lost. And may all Your enemies be quickly cut off and all the deliberate sinners, quickly uproot, break down, crush and subdue, quickly in our time. Blessed be You, YHVH, who breaks enemies and subdues deliberate sinners.”

— From the daily Jewish prayer, Amidah


This blessing is the famous 19th benediction of the Amidah even though the Amidah is called the Shemoneh Esrei, which means "18". The sages added this blessing later in Jewish history, when many Jews were collaborating with the Romans who were ruling the country at that time.


It is difficult to imagine that when the sages first composed the Amidah, there was no prayer that G-d protect us from our enemies. After all, the Jewish people have had enemies since the beginning of our history. As we recite in the Passover Haggadah, "In every generation they come upon us to destroy us?" Why, then, did the sages not include this blessing from the very beginning?


At that time in our history, there arose a new enemy — the malshanim, slanderers. These were not Non-Jews. They were Jews who were undercover apostates and slandered their fellow Jews to the foreign government ruling in Israel, causing disastrous problems for the community. There were so many malshanim at the time that almost every Jew was suspect. The Talmud recalls that if a cantor leading the prayer service began to stutter at his recital of this blessing, he was immediately suspected of being an enemy of the people.



COMPASSION ON THE ENEMY
The sages and prophets of the Great Assembly wrote the Amidah with great precision. Therefore, it was a critical matter to choose the right person to write this additional blessing. After serious deliberation, the Great Assembly chose Shmuel HaKatan, "Little Shmuel."

Why couldn't any one of the sages write this request? Is it really that difficult to express the desire to wipe out our enemies? Yes, it should indeed be difficult to express such thoughts.


Shmuel Hakatan was known in Pirkei Avos (part of the Mishna called "Ethics of the Fathers") for saying, "When your enemy falls, do not take joy." Someone who finds any joy in destroying another person could not have written this blessing with the necessary precision. Shmuel HaKatan had the right intention — love for G-d, not hate for people. Through the teachings of Shmuel HaKatan, we learn that a Jew should want our enemies to repent and ascend higher in their service to G-d. And if indeed war is unavoidable, as was the case of Pinchas, then it must be waged with the deepest sense of love for G-d and not hatred for people.


We now can see the tremendous love for G-d this blessing required. Anybody can write a blessing that expresses the desire for our enemies to fall. The words "kill them," "destroy them," "wipe them from the face of the earth," come to mind. Only someone with the purest of intentions — solely out of love for G-d, and without any hate whatsoever — could have the precise attitude required to express the ideal desires of generations of Jewish people.


A close reading of the blessing reveals its accuracy. It does not say, "Slice them into little pieces" or "torture them." Rather, it describes a corrective process — tikkun. We first ask G-d to cause the "malshanim" — to give up all hope that their diabolical scheming will have any impact. Then, "within one moment all evil be lost from the earth." Note that it does not ask for "rashaim" (evil people) to be lost, but "rishah" (evilness).

In his book Midos Haraaya, Rabbi Avraham Yitzchak Kook explains that whenever we pray that G-d deal with our enemies, we never pray for the destruction of the enemy himself, only his evilness. We do not want to see people die unless there is no other way to stop them from doing evil.


The continuation of the prayer is provocative: "and may all Your enemies be quickly cut off." Cut off from where? Why doesn't it say, "Kill them"? There are many ways to define the phrase "cut off." It can mean end their supply, discontinue their support or cause them to lose their footing (and perhaps even their funding), among other things. A careful reading of the Amidah reveals that we do not want our enemies to be killed, just defeated.


In the end, we ask G-d only to subdue them. But the repentance of our enemies is a long process. First, they must be uprooted so they have no grounding. Then they must be broken down and humbled. We could pray, "May You be abundantly manifest as one who kills and destroys our enemies." But that's not how the blessing ends. Instead, it exhorts, "May You be abundantly manifest as one who breaks enemies and humbles deliberate sinners." Clearly, this blessing was written with tremendous love and sensitivity, in the hope that evilness — not evil ones — will be cast from the earth.


Indeed, Judaism teaches that we must not ask for the sinners to be lost from the land, but rather that the sins be lost from the land. We learn this lesson from the Talmudic story of Bruria. The wife of great sage Rebbe Meir, Bruria was well known as a Torah Scholar a woman possessing vast Torah knowledge. The story goes that a man shares with her that there is someone in his community who is harassing him, and he is praying for G-d to destroy him.


"You fool!" she admonishes him. "The verse in Psalms states, "May the sins be cast off from the land" — not the sinners. In other words, we pray that sinners repent, not die.


There is a remarkable Midrash that relates that Pharaoh, the one of the greatest enemies of the Jewish people, suffered from leprosy. His advisors tell him that bathing in Jewish blood can cure the ailment, so Pharaoh orders his men to slaughter Jewish children for this purpose. Another Midrash, however, explains that after the exodus from Egypt, Pharaoh repents and gets a new job as king of Ninveh. In the story of Jonah, G-d commands Jonah to go to Ninveh and tell the people there to repent. When Jonah finally arrives with G-d's command, the king says, "I know this G-d. Let us not start up with Him." All the people of Ninveh then repent.


Judaism has such a forgiving attitude toward our enemies that the greatest thing we can do for them is to pray for their repentance. This is an incredible testimony that we are supposed to want those who kill us to repent form their evil ways rather than die.



SUMMARY AND PARAPHRASED
This prayer should be said with tremendous love for G-d and not hate for people. It expresses our hope that evilness — not evil ones — be cast from the earth; that G-d's enemies and those who sin against Him be subdued and repent.


And as for the slanderers, those who vilify their fellow Jews to foreign governments, may they not have hope and therefore, stop scheming against us and may all the evilness (not the enemy himself, but only his evilness) in one moment be lost. Motivated by our love for You and not because of personal vendetta we ask: and may all YOUR enemies be quickly cut off from any backing or support that sustains their wickedness so that they will quickly capitulate in defeat; and all the deliberate sinners, quickly uproot, (cause them to lose their footing and falter) break down, crush and subdue, (progressively humbling them towards total surrender and repentance) quickly in our time. Blessed be You, — May You be abundantly manifest G-d, who breaks enemies and subdues deliberate sinners.


The more we believe that G-d is always breaking enemies and subduing sinners and we sincerely want to free ourselves from their threat, the more the blessings for love and peace can penetrate and become manifest in our midst.

About Mollah Mohammad Omar

In April 1996, supporters of Mullah Muhammad Omar bestowed on him the title Amir al-Mu'minin (أمير المؤمنين, "Commander of the Faithful"), after he donned a cloak alleged to be that of Hazrat Muhammad (SAWS) which was locked in a series of chests, held inside the Mosque of the Cloak of the Prophet Mohammed (SAWS) in the city of Kandahar. Legend decreed that whoever could retrieve the cloak from the chest would be the great Leader of the Muslims, or "Amir al-Mu'minin".


Mullah Muhammad Omar has been described as shy and non-talkative with foreigners. During 1996-2001 he seldom left the city of Kandahar and rarely met with outsiders.


Many current and former U.S. senior military officials such as Robert Gates, Stanley McChrystal, David Petraeus and others claim that Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps are also involved in helping the Taliban.


In September 1996, Kabul fell to Mullah Omar and his followers. His Government was recognized by Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. A "reclusive, pious and frugal" leader, Omar visited Kabul twice between 1996 to 2001. Omar stated: "All Taliban are moderate. There are two things: extremism ["ifraat", or doing something to excess] and conservatism ["tafreet", or doing something insufficiently]. So in that sense, we are all moderates – taking the middle path.


In a BBC's Pashto interview after the September 11 attacks in 2001, he told that "You (the BBC) and American puppet radios have created concern. But the current situation in Afghanistan is related to a bigger cause - that is the destruction of America...This is not a matter of weapons. We are hopeful for Allah's help. The real matter is the extinction of America. And, Allah willing, it [America] will fall to the ground... We will not accept a government of wrong-doers. We prefer death than to be a part of an evil government..."

-Excerpts from Wikipedia

I’m Harun Baul Speaking (Part – 19) -By Prof.Md.Amzad Hossain, Australia

If the mind is not simple and straight, there is no benefit in searching. It is fruitless to pretend to be good. When mind is pure, even if someone’s expressions are blunt; God is not unpleased with that – says Lalon).

---------------------------------
Lile dheke lage voy
Naukar upor gonga bojhai
Dangai boia jai - Lalon
(To observe a play is fearful when ‘the river is loaded on the boat to race through the dry land’).

My guru Aziz Shah Fakir did clearly mention in I‘M HARUN BAUL SPEAKING (part 18) revealing that unnecessary discussions with corrupted political parties were going to be the greatest of all blunders for the DRIVERS of present Bangladesh. This prophecy of the guru is coming clearer day by day. The indication to free the top corrupts under the threatened pressures from some political terrorists leads the guru to believe that the DRIVERS are conceding defeat. They also seem to have lost the strength for running the country to maintain the law and order situation functional as expected.

The guru stresses that the DRIVERS are responsible for the emerging fearful situation. The reason lies in the songs my guru sings these days more frequently than ever before:

Jokhon vitai hao bosoti
Dia ele khosh kobluti
Hrdame naam rakhbo sthiti, vuleso kire.
Ain mafik nirikh dena
Tate keno itorpona?
A din jabere jabere jana, jana jebe akhere - Lalon

(When you were established in the seat (of Driver), you pledged (in) a covenant that you would always remember your duties – have you forgotten that? Why deviate from discharging legitimate functions? You must bear the consequences at the end.)

The guru’s present spiritual craving is especially directed to MORALITY and PATRIOTISM related matters of the DRIVERS of the country. The DRIVERS seem to have grossly deviated from their initial VOWs for a fair election with the participation of HONEST and COMPETENT candidates; and uprooting of rampant corruption. Now the DRIVERS’ leaning towards things beyond the original VOWS are being increasingly questioned by people making the DRIVERS disrespectable, insecure.

The above song should helps the DRIVERS recollect about their promise for a fair election consisting of HONEST and COMPETENT citizens at all levels. They also promised to purge and uproot corruption at all levels of government, non-government and corporate bodies. At this stage of DRIVING the country, it appears that the DRIVERS have now grossly deviated from their original commitments. Now, they are unwisely, unnecessarily and often counter-productively negotiating with political parties widely known to people as non-patriotic, exploitative, power hungry, out and out corrupt and misuser of power and money, and political terror.

The guru prophesies that if the arrested politicians are released without being properly investigated, they, in association with their party terrors, will again contest in all levels of elections. As usual, they will use money and muscle power, and apply vote terrorism. The voters will be forced and compelled to vote for their party candidates. They will win. Kicking off all the good laws against corruption, they will, naturally, try their utmost to make good all their losses, and realise much wanted profits. DRIVERS will be in similar situation as many top corrupts are in at the moment. Many of the DRIVERS’ innocent subordinates would also be under revengeful actions.

The guru also prophesies that the defeated parties will unite, start the hartal (general strike ) culture again, blockade supplies, facilitate socio-economic crimes to sky rocket and so on. The guru asserts that a good possibility of civil war to break out between the exploiters and the exploited will arise. All these are known to the DRIVERS, if they have read history. Knowing all these why are the DRIVERS engendering counter-leadership to emerge is yet to be known. However, the guru is of the opinion that the DRIVERS are in a gross deviation from their original two pledges.

The guru now seems to believe that the DRIVERS are not as SIMPLE and as PATRIOTIC as they initially appeared to be; and that is why they are not morally strong enough to go for the pledged socio-political reformation with the conviction: Montrer shadhon kimba sharir pothon - ‘to do or die’.

SIMPLICITY and PATRIOTISM – these two essential moral values and their synergistic outcomes are the only need for our country at the moment to stay ‘THRIVING’ instead of the present condition of ‘STRIVING’ in every respect. This is why the guru also sings:

Na hole mon sarala ki phal hobe kotha dhure.
Hathe hathe berao mise tauba pore.
Mon jar hoese khati , mukhe jodi galad pore;
Khoda tathe naraj noyre, Lalon vere – Lalon Fakir

(If the mind is not simple and straight, there is no benefit in searching. It is fruitless to pretend to be good.

When mind is pure, even if someone’s expressions are blunt; God is not unpleased with that – says Lalon).

With the recession of bomb-terrorism countrywide, an increasing emergence of political terrorism to nullify corruption charges against the top corrupts of the major political parties is getting furious day by day. The proverb ‘CHORE CHORE MASTUT BHAI’ – all thieves are cousins - is coming clear. The DRIVERS’ (legitimate) administrative steps in order to prevent the corrupts and incompetent from taking part in the forthcoming elections is suffering from a complete uncertainty.

Under the above unsustainable and chaotic situation, the guru has sought advise from his wife guru ma Laily Shah Fakirani, who is known as a multi-genius feminist activist amongst their devotees. It may be mentioned here that male Bauls treat their wives as guide-cum-associates (guru). Decision-making leadership is vested with women – the source of Sakti (vital energy) for individual, family, social, political, economic and ecological sustainability (holistic sustainability) of a country.

Guru ma Laily Shah Fakirani first gives her views on the recent and still unresolved issue of women’s equal rights demanded by some feminist of pro-Western Godless secularism. The guru ma asserts that if the issue is resolved in favour of the so called secularist’s claim and implemented before the forthcoming national and local elections, then in accordance with equal rights claim women cannot deserve 30% reserved seats in the parliament any more and must compete with the men candidates. It would be a disaster for women. Neither many women would compete in the rural areas, nor the voters including women voters would vote for the women candidates because of some practical impediments.

The most obvious one is that women members cannot cope with the diverse political and social situation where their physical presence is required. This is not practical in rural areas because of women’s physical, social, and unfavourable natural and environmental conditions that normally restrict women’s movement freely. Regarding the issue of 50% of inheritance, the guru ma says that it would drag in the concept of 50% of everything including family’s economic responsibility where women will be the worst looser, on the one hand; and it will ruin the family-life structure, bondage, and upbringing and engendering of children, on the other. It would be totally disastrous as it has been in the West where marriage between the same sex is rightful in the name of human rights.

At this ponit, the guru ma asks the guru to sing in order to indicate the pathway for the DRIVERS.

Chatak swavab na hoile.
Amrita megher bari
Kathai ki mele?- Lalon

(Without acquiring the values of the bird Chataka (swallow), is rain water available only by prayer?)

Chand dhora fand jano na mon.
Nehar nai tomar lafa fafi shar,
Ek laaf die dhorte chao gagan.- Lalon.

(You do not know how to trap a thing. You do not have a conviction. You are busy for nothing productive. You wish to cross all the barriers with one jump).

In the first song the guru ma suggests that the DIVERS should acquire and manifest the value ‘perseverance’ like the swallows do and wait for rain to come as their drinking water. In the second song it is indicated that the DRIVERS are not artful enough to accomplish the desirable outcome. They rather want to reach the unreachable. This would not work in the current situation. The DRIVERS need to concentrate on their pledge for free and fair election with honest and competent associates. This would facilitate the DRIVERS to become strong enough to address the threatening demand for freeing arrested.

In order to strengthen the DRIVERS’ position, the guru ma repeats the essence of the discourse I’ M HARUN BAUL SPEAKING (part 18) that was first published on April 29, 2008 and continued till May 7, 2008. It pleaded for an inclusivistic Sufistic political party with religio-cultural inclusivism like that of Tariqat Federation in order to address and fill the ongoing widening of political vacuum. Practicing religio-cultural intellectuals such as Fatemolla and socio- economic reformist civil servant like Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) Chairman Hon. Lt Gen (retd.) Hasan Mashhud Chowdhury are suggested to come forward with their voices in support of the stated election manifesto and guidelines for recruiting HONEST and COMPETENT candidates that guru Aziz Shah Fakir has revealed:

1.Fish and fruit/tree for everyone

(Everyone needs fish and fruit trees. They can be achieved if the people in power want them and know how to implement the project. To avail fish and fruits for everyone will warrant a massive work in the area of water resource development, reduction of unsustainable fishing and fish export, and reduction in the cost of irrigation. Plantation of fruit trees on the roadsides throughout the country will alone help avail fruits for those who have no place to grow them).

2. Full support for the people willing to work overseas

(Almost every family wants to send a family member overseas. The government can implement this project giving financial support to those who are in need. To produce exportable manpower with ‘quality and skill’ will lead the education sector to introduce moral (values) education at the primary level and appropriate skill development education and training at the secondary sector).

3. Facilities for small-scale industrial productivity

(80% of families need extra income; it will minimise imports to a great extent and employ lot of women at home. To support rural households and city slums with cottage industries will benefit low income earners in the one hand, and reduce imports, on the other).

4. To narrow down the lifestyle gaps between rich and poor

(This can be achieved through a national policy which motivates the rich to come closer to the poor in their dress and food habit; addressing elderly poor with ‘Apni’ instead of ‘Tumi’; and sharing each other’s joys and sorrows. Once this policy is widely known, both rich and poor would accept it. According to guru ma, a national policy with wide manifestation of better off people’s brotherhood/sisterhood mannerism with the worse off folks (sub-ordinates, employees, servants, labourers); a habit of sharing food, dress, affordable money, and joys and sorrows with the havenots; the well off’s visit to poor neighbourhood and hospitals; modest and simple lifestyle in terms of dress –all these will automatically bring down poverty both materially and psychologically. The poor will be friends of the rich. Alleviation of poverty is neither possible in the geo-environmental and cultural conditions of Bangladesh, nor it is at all desirable for the sake of a long-term sustainability of the county. A poverty-like modest (i.e. sustainable) lifestyle is, therefore, an imperative not only for this country, but also for the globe).

5. Equitable foreign policy

(Relationship with foreign countries on the basis of social, economic and environmental sustainability equity)

Suggestions on recruiting HONEST and COMPETENT Associates

4 ward Associates including a female;

2 union Associates, a male and a female);

1 Thana and 1 constituency Associates.

(the Associates will be trained before the election on how to present the five election agenda as above and the national and local development commitments as bellow, along with the implementation procedures (yet to design). InshAllah, voters will come forward to vote for these candidates and bear the essential election costs, where needed).

Selected Associates’ Election Commitments

1. National Commitments:

a. Establishment of a national TV centre, namely the Tariqat TV

(the TV centre will be dedicated to promote sustainable development including cultural reformation, values education and exportable manpower development)

b. The religious leaders would be financially supported where needed

c. The teachers would be subsidised for excursion

2. LocalCommitments:

a. Wardwise institution development where needed (mosque, primary or high school, madrasa or maktab, mazar, dargah or khanka based community centre)

b. Wardwise cooperative society cum fair price stores

c. Wardwise colour television

d. Wardwise cultural development group

e. Wardwise female welfare worker (there is no elected female member)

f. Wardwise pond-cum-fruit tree garden to serve the local poor

g. Wardwise Charity (Zakat) fund to help the needy.

My guru ma says that No political party – large or small – should rely on the backdoor negotiation of the present DRIVERS of Bangladesh. At the same time, no DRIVERS should give any unspecified support to any political party. Political partnerships between the politicians and the bureaucrats have often caused the partners into the jail afterward.

What is urgently needed is that the present DRIVERS of the country ought to publicly allow the ACC Chairman to speak about the above manifesto and commitments for the Tariqat Federation. If they fail to grasp the latent potential and viability of the manifested agenda and commitments; then, on behalf of the Election Commission itself, a campaign should be soonest initiated in order to form a Sufistic inclusivistic new political party (namely, Bangladesh Sufi Party – BSP) to be established under the guidance and leadership of the present ACC Chairperson himself, and the Fatemollas home and abroad.

The following is a DRAFT Application Form for recruiting HONEST and COMPETENT associates:

. Type of associate you are applying for: Ward/Union, Thana, Constituency

. Name, address, age, education etc.

. Income, expenditure, assets and liabilities statement.

. What has made you honest?

. List the development works needed in your area.

. What percentage of votes you would expect with the above manifesto and commitments?

. Number of voters willing to go overseas from your area requiring financial help.

. Number of aged/widows need support.

. What percentage of voters would like the Tariqat TV centre?

. What percentage of voters support NGO activities?

. What percentage of voters would appreciate a community centre with a cooperative shop, ponds, fruit trees, a library, a colour TV and sewing and handicraft training?

. What percentage of voters would appreciate a male and a female development worker for health care and agricultural training in your locality?

. What percentage of votes would for you if the above are pledged?

. How many persons are likely to stand against you in the forthcoming election?

. Will your voters donate for printing of pamphlets and for campaigning?

. If you are selected by the party, would you like to communicate the central office of the party directly or through your local office?

. If you win the election, how would you start your activity?

. If values and skill development education is made compulsory at primary and secondary level, how will it benefit the country?

Please get 4 respectable persons (2 religious leaders and 2 teachers) from within your election jurisdiction to sign below to testify that you are HONEST and COMPETENT, and YOU WILL WIN THE ELECTION.

I’m Harun Baul Speaking ( part -15) -by Prof. M.Amzad Hossain

According to Bauls, excessive consumption, wasteful lifestyle, and piling up of wealth and money that are considered socially, religiously and environmentally immodest or extravagant are illusive.


*************************
I’m Harun Baul Speaking
*************************
Baul’s views on social, economic and environmental sustainability management are more focused on people than technologies. In order to inform people about their individual sustainability issues such as mortality, acquisition of wealth, consumption habits, lifestyle etc., Bauls depict this world as a place of transit to human’s next destination – eternal or cyclical.

Bauls, therefore, cry:
Silam kotha, elam hetha,
Jabo kotha, vebe mori. – Lalon Fakir

(Where have I been before, where am I now, and where will I go next - I think about it relentlessly).

The persistent thinking about mortality of all living beings moves the Baul mind that manifests itself as one of their philosophical values. They remain indifferent to illusive engagement while doing worldly activities. According to Bauls, excessive consumption, wasteful lifestyle, and piling up of wealth and money that are considered socially, religiously and environmentally immodest or extravagant are illusive. All are utterly anti-sustainable. Bauls are shocked observing that the more a person is formally educated (Pundit), the more s/he is materially egocentric. In contrast, the laity people demonstrate a better sociality and civility over the Pundits’. Lalon Fakir warns:

Tumi ba kar keba tomar
a bhaba samsare?
Misse mayai mojia mon
ki karore?

(Who do you belong to and who belong to you

during this worldly life?

Engaging in falls illusion
what do you do?).

Lalon informs people about the hard reality of this worldly life where people are apt to engage themselves in illusive activities pertaining to their personal, social and political matters. Corruption and crime in order to acquire money and power depict people’s strong attachment to illusionary activities, which are currently pervasive in socio-political scenarios of Bangladesh.

My guru Aziz Shah Fakir (93) of Charaikole. Kushtia discourses that time tells people what to do. A time has now come for Bangladeshi people to reinforce themselves with the lost politico-moral values. This is an easily achievable way out for people to graduate from current politico-social tyranny into a sustainable political environment where social, economic and environmental justice prevails. Most politicians are now far off from their professional ethics and cultural values such as honesty and simple living. Rather, they are engaged in all sorts of corruption and crime. It is now an open secret that most dangerous muggers are some politicians’ own creation.

In the past, the tradition/culture of plain living and high thinking was the politicians’ way of life. Now a days politicians are just opposite of what they aught to be. They consume bestially divulging their utter selfishness. MPs spend large amounts of money to win elections and they consider this spending as a profitable investment. The widening trends in politicians’ corruption and crime are largely to recover their widening financial investment during their election campaign. Such a practice alone has largely ruined our pro-people political culture.

The guru urges for new leadership to encounter this grievous situation. He predicts that the majority of our population would support a new leadership provided the leadership is an inclusivist like a Baul guru or a Sufi saint. Both Baulism and Sufism teach socio-religious and environmental inclusivism. They utterly oppose exclusion of people on the basis of their social strata or religious identity. They believe that

Bhaktir dvare bandha asse sain.

Hindu ki jobon bole jather bichar nai. Lalon Fakir

(Creator is receptive to devotion. He is indifferent of the religions of Hindus and Muslims).

Guru Aziz Shah Fakir even opposes exclusion of environmental goods (species) from economic activities. His un-compromising attitude towards any sort of mono-culture in agriculture and selective pisciculture manifest his inclusivistic conviction. The guru sees inclusivism as one of human values, which is generated out of the synergy between two or more (ethical) values such as honesty, simplicity, charity, kindness, (cultural) compatibility, environmentalism, naturalism etc.

Acquiring Baul inclusivism is, thus, a way out for Bangladesh to acquire all values in one value pack - inclusivism. The guru stresses that inclusivism is a moral software for holistic sustainability management, including politics. Inclisivism makes people auto-political, literate and wise.

Bauls are though judged as ‘illiterate’ within a written culture, but hearing their innumerable songs, one cannot but regard them as supreme Pundits of sustainability wisdom. My guru stresses that his grand guru’s (Dada guru’s) guru Lalon Fakir did not read any religious books, but in discussing religion, he displayed an extraordinary knowledge of the Scriptures. The guru says: We do not believe in writing down our spontaneously composed songs. We sing as we go along, and as feelings come to us.

Lalon depicts how the lack of persistent inclusivism compells Pundits to seek knowledge from the laity:

Lila dekhe lage bhoy.
Naukar upor gonga bojhai,
dangai baye jai.

(It is frightening to see that the river Ganges is loaded on the boat and runs through the dry land).

Messages hidden in this song invoke today’s problems. Things are turning upside down. Economy, sociality, environment – all are showing irregular (opposite) trends. Pundits from home and abroad now seek local knowledge from the rural illiterate elders in pursuance of achieving the best practices for sustainable development. This is an indication of Pundit’s educational poverty. This is as if the Ganges has so little water that it seeks help from the boats in order to keep flowing. Naukar upor gonga bojhai, dangai baye jai.

Although the pundits engaged in rural developmental work have already caused a lot of damages to global social, economic and environmental sustainability, Bangladesh has not yet reached the point of no return. Some basic/simple socio-cultural, religious, economic, environmental, educational and political reforms can revitalise the spirit of Bangladesh, resembling the vibrant sustainability scenarios in the 1950s.

My guru emphatically says that in order to revitalise Bangladesh, people need no help from the outsiders and their local agents; rather people should say ‘good bye’ to the outsiders, and re-educate their local agents to remove their illusion/ignorance. NGO bosses have forgotten about the socio-economic and environmental reality and potential of the country. They have lost our traditional values. They need to receive values education for their own sake and for the sake of others. The sooner this happens, the better for the sustainability of Bangladesh.

The Guru stresses that values education for sustainability will help NGO operators realise that Bangladesh need no borrowing from outsiders. The country has enough local resources for generating self-reliant sustainability. Self-reliant sustainability is an ecosystemic state/norm where people intra-dependently create a synergy towards enjoying self-sufficiency in basic needs – food, shelter and clothing. Education for acquiring values and occupational skill automatically flows in order to sustain the state of self-reliance. My guru’s devotees can provide outcome-based education to NGO operators, focusing the precepts and practices of sustainable development in local contexts.

My guru suggests that an NGO must work in a particular locality, with a mission to achieve sustainable development in social, economical and environmental contexts of the area. It is suggested that even more than one NGO can conjointly operate in a locality undertaking the responsibility for holistic sustainable development of the locality. Any particular NGO must not be allowed to run all over the country, showing no positive, visible and sustainable outcome. NGOs are frequently blamed for cheating poor people. This also must be stopped.

NGOs are part of Green Revolution (GR) technology transfer. My guru is utterly against the GR technologies. He claims that though the GR technology tripled food production in just a few decades, it also has created a wide range of problems. Some of these are pollution of water bodies by farm chemicals, accelerated land degradation, increased pressure on water supplies, loss of genetic variability in crops, enhanced vulnerability in crops, enhanced vulnerability to pest and crop diseases. It has also brought a series of social and cultural problems, including widening the economic gap between affluent and the poor farmers.

The guru also stresses that exploitative forms of economic growth, devastative forms of social changes since the birth of the nation have accelerated the technological transformation (of nature), generating ecological imbalances and degrading the basis of sustainability of our economic order. This process has led to degrade natural resources and a decline in ecosystems’ productive potential.

To reverse the situation, guru Aziz Shah Fakir reveals that knowledge of the productive practices and cultural values of traditional societies appears as an important point of departure for developing innovative technological systems that could more adequately utilize the productive potential of ecosystems without degrading them. Productive practices are articulated with the values of each community, with their consumption patterns, with their socially sanctioned access to resources, and with their religious beliefs.

The guru maintains that in order to re-achieve our ecosystemic health, we need an alternative political party to emerge. The party is to be formed by the inclusivists. Baul followers and the followers of Sufi saints such as Khaja Moinuddin Chisty are all inclusivists. People from all social strata and religious beliefs have reverence for Lalon Fakir, the Chisty and their Khalifas (successors), because of their open demonstration of social, religious and environmental inclusivism.

Contrarily, the followers of a religio-political party and the Wahabis in Bangladesh are exclusivists. They exclude all humans from their folds except a few Muslims who are far less respectful to the Prophet and his descendants than that of the rest of the believers – followers of Baulism and diverse Sufism.

In 1801 Wahhabi forces raiding Iraq destroyed the dome of the tomb of Imam Husayn in Kerbala. More than a century later, when the Saudi family consolidated the hold of its monarchy over Arabia, they carried out a massive demolition of all the tombs in Medina, particularly the tombs of the Imams and members of the family of Mohammad.

The guru has the information that there was even a proposal to raze the tomb of the Prophet Mohammad in the name of preventing so-called idolatrous worship of him, but the structure was preserved as part of the original mosque of Medina. The anniversary of this destruction of the ‘eternal Paradise’ cemetery in 1925 is still marked by Shi’is with great sadness.

As recently as 1990, a senior Saudi religious official, Shaykh Bin Jibrin, declared that Shi’is deserve to be killed. It is clear that the motives of the exclusivists in combating pilgrimage to Mazars are political - not theological. The guru, thus, asserts that the politics of the exclusivists must be denied in Bangladesh, as our people’s (irrespective of religious denomination) spirituality is Mazar centric.

Guru Aziz Shah urges Bangladeshi inclusivists to soon come forward to form a new political party – say, Bangladesh Soth Party (BSP) - in line with Sufi political philosophy of inclusivism. Applying inclusivism, the medieval Sufis overwhelmed the world in terms of Islamisation. The guru affirms that more that 80% of Bangalee Muslims and most non-Muslims would support the party, because of its inclusivistic attitudes – the true secularism.

The guru reveals that a true secularism exists where people can acquire their respective religio-cultural values intrinsically and manifest them synergistically. This type of secularism will bury socio-religious conflicts as well as the dynastic democracy of the country. It will narrow down the materialistic gaps between rich and poor. It will function on the Straight Path – the Path of the Creator’s blessed personages.

The guru identifies the Scriptural blessed personages as those who are frequently visited by general mass, even after their apparent death/disappearance. Immorality such as corruption and crime is irrelevant in a society where people follow the lifestyle of the blessed personages who live/d their lives in line with the Scriptural revelations: One who amasses wealth and counts it, and thinks that his/her wealth would make him/her immortal. S/he will certainly experience the taste of crushing fire of hell (Huthama).

Guru Aziz Shah Fakir reveals that there is no ground for Bangladeshi people to be unfairly. Naturally, Bangladesh is country of sustainable self-reliance. Politicians need not make the country foreign (aid) dependant. There is no need for trade-tied aid from outsiders. Bangladesh lacks certain resources, which can be procured from exporting countries of these resources in exchange of our surplus wealth - manpower, medicinal and jute products, tea, vegetables, fruits. Fish is not surplus in Bangladesh; so fish export must be stopped. There is no need to give too much importance to the exploitative WTO, World Bank and IMF. Bangladesh still can import from and export to other countries, as it did for centuries in the past.

The guru claims that the importation of too many motorised vehicles is a social, economical and environmental crime. The vehicles not only claim a number of lives every day, it destroys cultural, economic and environmental norms of the country. A tiny land with 145 million people and hundreds of rivers is perfect for non-motorised vehicles and river boats. This would reduce road accidents, reduce imports and employ greater number of people in transport sectors than that of at present. This would also lead to increase land and water biodiversity/resources, and sustain the ecosystem health.

The guru reveals that human health is integrally related to ecosystem health. The Baul and Sufi devotees internalise ecosystemic norms in their day-to-day livelihoods. They pursue diverse religio-cultural rituals in order to comprehend nature’s own health management techniques. This is because they understand that human health management is not an isolated case from ecosystem health. It depends highly on the quality of the environment in which people live: for people to be healthy, they need healthy environments.

To accomplish all the needful things, the guru emphasises the need for a healthy political system. He asks the political leaders to sit together, dissolute their respective political parties and support BSP with presidential system of democracy. All political leaders must conjointly agree to eliminate the culture of spending money to win elections. Political corruption starts from here. The elected members are compelled to steal public money and wealth in order to (re)compensate their expenses plus profits. Consequently, Bangladesh people have been like a donkey turning a mill. The donkey goes round and round on its own track and never makes any advance.

Guru Aziz Shah Fakir observes that the sustainability icon for Bangladesh has two components - physical and non-physical. The physical components are natural resources, population and technologies including energy supply. Culture, poverty and political performance constitute the non-physical components. While the physical elements conjointly constitute a vehicle for progress, a transition toward a sustainable future of the country, the others generate ‘values’ that drive the vehicle. As the traditional values for sustainability management are gradually degrading because of the current state of the country’s educational policy and political system, the physical components are not being appropriately or optimally explored. This is where our sustainability problems lie. In order to find a pathway to future sustainability, the proposed (BSP) politics is undeniable. (To be continued).

Md. Amzad Hossain
Perth
Australia

Ecocracy of Khelafat system needs to be revived and implanted -Prof.M. Amzad Hossain

I am Harun Baul Speaking (Part 22)


আমার দেখে শুনে জ্ঞান হল না।

কি করিতে কি করিলাম দুগ্ধেতে মিশালাম চোনা।

মদন রাজার ডঙ্কা ভারি

হলাম রে তার আজ্ঞাকারি

জার মাটিতে বসত করি

চিরদিন তারে চিন্লাম না। লালন ফকির

Amar dekhe shune gnan holo na.

Ki korite ki korilam, dugdhete mishalam chona.

Modon rajar donka vari, holam re tar agnakari

Jar matithe boshot kori

Chiro din tare chinlam na. Lalon Fakir

(I learn not from listening, seeing.

To do things right I err like mixing urine with milk.

I have become wish-bearer of powerful king Modon - lust.

Living in someone’s land I never bother to know Him). Lalon Fakir


According to Guru Aziz Shah Fakir the song reveals the four-fold evils such as stubbornness, willful erring, greed and ignorance have inflicted most of our people in power. The progressive deterioration of sustainability in all sectors of the country including foreign affairs, political, economic, social, moral, law and order, and ecological conditions bear the witness. He considers the rising trend towards the worst as an indication of a potential social revolution. A revolution is of course desirable for retreat facilitating the emergence of a new era with a new set of revolutionary people enriched with values and spirituality of Sufism, and new governance for restoration of our degrading sustainability. The guru is elated about it, for a new governance would hopefully cause to end the inherently oppressive, exploitative and corrupt western democracy in one hand, and implant a righteous democracy embedded in the spirit of Khelafat system of deliberative governance, on the other. To help restore historic Sonar Bangla, the guru outlines a guideline for establishing the Khelafat system of governance largely compatible to our sustainability icons:


নদী ভরা জল

মাঠ ভরা ফসল

পুকুর ভরা মাছ

গোয়াল ভরা গরু

বাড়ী ভরা গাছ

পাখির কলতান

শিশুর কোলাহল

বাউলের ও মাঝির গান

রাতে বন্য জন্তু ও ভূতের ভয়।



nadi vora jol (water in river),

math vora sashya (field full of crops),

pukur vora maas (pond full of fish),

gohal vora garu (cow in the cowshed),

bari vora gaas (homestead with trees),

pakhir kolotan (melodious tune of the birds),

shisur koahol (uproar of children),

bauler o majheer gaan (songs of Bauls and boatmen),

Rathe banya jantu O vuther voy (fear of wild animals and ghosts at night)



The guru would call the new era as the era of ‘Ecocracy’ (ecological democracy). The Ecocracy of the historic Khelafat system needs to be revived and intrinsically implanted at National, Thana, Union and Ward level. Firstly, a national Khelafat committee can be constituted with 2 representatives (1 male, 1 female) from each of the like-minded (pro-Sufi) political parties. This integrated committee can recruit a national recruiting body consisting of 50% male and 50% female members. They should be distinguished practicing individuals of various disciplines who are laudable for their stewardship values such as patriotism, competence, trustworthiness, honesty and resilience. With the expertise of the national recruiting committee, the national Khelafat committee can recruit 1 male and 1 female Ward Khalifas, Union Khalifas and Thana Khalifas throughout the country. There may not be any Khalifas at the district level. The districts can be administered by a team of patriotic civil servants.

The selection process must be based on the basis of merits of the candidates as outlined in “I am Harun Baul Speaking (part 19  http://www.bangladesh-web.com/view.php?hidRecord=202958)”. The selected Ward Khalifas can then recruit one male and one female member from the Ward Gotras (clans) to form an Integrated Ward Khelafat Committee. The national Khelafat committee and national recruiting committee jointly can form the Thana Committees who can form the Union Committees in their respective unions. Both the Thana and the Union committees need to be selected strictly on the basis of merits of the candidates.

The Khalifas at all levels may be given honorarium to meet their basic living costs. They will work from their respective Ward Community Centre which will be constructed in every Ward. The centre should be large enough to accommodate a training centre, a healthcare facility, a food security go-down, a crop bank, a cooperative shop, a ration shop, an organic fertilizer centre, a permissible entertainment facility, a Shalish Kendra etc.

The local agenda with regards to social, economic and ecological issues must be identified and prioritized locally reflecting the deliberative wisdom of the local people including the local elders. The resolved matters and any unresolved ones (legal matters etc.) including any socio-economic conflicts and future development plans are to be forwarded to the Union and Thana Khalifas. The Thana Khalifas will endeavour to resolve them. The yet-unresolved matters will be sent to the National committee. This bottom-up functionality clearly means that a Ward Community Centre is the primary hub of community activity. This model of governance, the guru claims, is a sustainable grassroots-based Ecocratic system.

The guru suggests that the National Khalifas have to be trained up by the guru’s authorised trainers on all aspects of the national election manifesto and ministerial framework as revealed in “I am Harun Baul Speaking part 21”.

The National Khalifas will train the Thana Khalifas who will train the Union Khalifas who will train the Ward Khalifas who will train the Ward Committee members who will implement development in their respective community.

The focus of training would be to reinforce Khelafat governance’s intrinsic capital such as patriotism, belief (Iman) and spiritual strength that can synergistically revitalise our degrading culture to advance a transition towards reviving our inherent cultural values such as caring for the environment, learning from nature, honesty and trustworthiness, responsibility and obligation, patience and resilience, and kindness and cooperation. The synergies between these values can transform the people of ignorance into “the people of integrated understanding”.

The guru asserts that a nation comprised of a people of understanding can cause to prevail a culture where the rulers are guided by the pious. The rulers of Indian sub-continent enjoyed this privilege during the time of Pir Minuddin Chisty of Ajmer (d. 1230), Pir Shah Jalal of Sylhet (d. 1384), to list a few. Under the guidance of the pious, rich are obliged to see the poor as their valued patrons, and the people in general understand themselves as the custodian of all in nature. Tyranny and exploitation have no chance to prevail under this circumstance.

On the contrary, the rulers devoid of the guidance from holy saints, and also the highly recognised pundits who venerate the western democracy often tend to talk like idiots, behave like blinds, and act like cheats. The advocacy for the highly profiteering micro-credit programs in order to push the country’s various types of poverty caused by both human (social and political) and natural causes into museums is a living example. The guru asserts that the previous proclamation made by a distinguished personality regarding poverty alleviation through the business of micro-credit has resulted in creating a massive destitution compared to its microscopic economic well-being. However, the socio-moral losses that our culture has already suffered due to this deceptive micro-credit business stand irrecoverable. To add salt to injury, another deceptive slogan is being made now-a-days. This is to trigger the marketing of values-driven social business with moral obligation to be undertaken by the university graduates. Again, it is being told that the social business shall put poverty into the museums. This is also a classic bluff.

The social business of indiscriminate sale and usage of mobile phones is at the root of some serious evils in Bangladesh. Blackmailing, cheating, mugging, extortion, robbery, theft, road accidents, mobile marriage, suicide, illicit relationship between male and females, watching of immoral scenarios, murder, potential damage to ear (and/or brain) from over-use - all have flourished hundred times greater than when it was not in use. Many students and non-students youths are being spoiled, even losing their lives, because of the evil use of mobile phones. Innumerable city parents pass their times in dreadful stress. It has also caused nutritional deficiency to many low income people. As the people first increase food consumption when they have extra money, so they decrease it when in deficit. The guru claims that wise distribution and morally acceptable use of mobile phones will gradually lead to abolish all the negative consequences significantly.

Recognizing the above unsustainable anti-values phenomena, the guru repeatedly asks the values-driven pro-Sufi political parties to act in unity for devising an action plan for effective values education program from the early childhood – not at the tertiary level as has been suggested in view of promoting so-called social business.

Beside enriching the primary and secondary school curriculum for values education, a dedicated TV centre is long due in order to facilitate moral and spiritual development of our people including children through moral advertisements, depicting the sayings and doings of the Sufis, Baul songs, religious discourses, educational drama, and sustainability-centric documentary shows including sustainable development activities in the country. A concerted effort is required to achieve this.

The political parties in context have so far failed even to come to a common platform for mutual discussion. But it is an imperative for creating a discussion based synergy for uniting the pro-Sufi political parties who can collectively motivate people to ignite a social movement. The time is substantially favourable now, but is running out fast. Missing this great opportunity this time may result in a missing for forever.

Lalon reminds:

সময় গেলে সাধন হবে না। .

দিন থাকিতে তিনের সাধন কেন করলে না।

জানো না মন খালেবিলে

মিন থাকে না জল শুকালে

কি হবে তার বাধাল দিলে

শুকনা মোহনায়।

অসময়ে কৃষি করে

মিছা মিছি খেটে মরে

গাছ যদি হয় বীজের জরে

ফল ত ধরে না। লালন ফকির

Somoy gele shadhon hobe na.

Din thakite thiner sadhon keno korle na.

Janona mon khale bile,

Min thake na jol shukale,

Shukna mohonay.

Osomoye krishi korile,

Misamisi khete more,

Gass jodi hoy bijer jore.,

Fol to dhore na. Lalon Fakir

(Futile is untimely contemplation. Why not complete for the three (brotherhood for social sustainability, modesty for economic sustainability and nature conservation for ecological sustainability). Know you not that fish never exist in the dried out wetlands? What result would it produce if a dam is constructed there? Even if plants grow because of quality seeds, fruiting never occurs).

Over two months have passed since the last discourse on “I am Harun Baul Speaking (part 21)” was published on April 24, 2012 in the News From Bangladesh describing a simple framework for a sustainable Khelafat governance in Bangladesh. Guru Aziz Shah Fakir is relentlessly discoursing about the need for and significance of the Khilafat governance not only for making Bangladesh a happy and sustainable country, but also for orchestrating of a sustainability showcase for the global socio-economic and political management. It is rather unusual that the dedicated political parties are hardly doing any visible endeavours to constitute a governance framework in light of the Khilafat democracy in congruence with Bangladesh’s pluralistic cultural and climatic conditions. The guru suggests that the political parties in context should foster the 'underlying' cultural basis of the country. Our culture is by and large a Sufism centric culture vibrant with spirituality, Milad Mahfil and Urs manifesting brotherhood, modesty and conservation of nature.

The guru, thus, urges:

মিছে মায়ায় মদ খেয়ো না

প্রাপ্ত পথ ভুলে যেও না

এবার গেলে আর হবে না

পরবি কয় যুগের পিছে ।

Misse mayai mod kheo na

prapto path bhule jeo na

Ebar gele ar hobe na

Porbi koy juger pisse.


(Do not follow prohibited paths under false temptations forgetting the sustainable pathway that you have been bestowed with. To miss opportunities this time will leave you behind time).

Saturday, June 30, 2012

How Muslim Brotherhood went from 7 members to Egypt's presidency -By NANCY A. YOUSSEF

CAIRO -- When Hassan al-Banna founded the Muslim Brotherhood in 1928, the membership was just seven people - al-Banna and six other workers in the port city of Suez, his only surviving sibling, 91-year-old brother Gamal, recalled recently. The British were in charge of Egypt then, and Hassan al-Banna feared that their rule would end Islam.

Al-Banna, a teacher and imam who preached in mosques and coffee shops alike, hoped that members of the Brotherhood would gradually introduce Islamic thought into the mainstream, so that one day Egypt's president and the society he led would be imbued with a shared way of thinking. He never contemplated, however, that the Brotherhood would become a political group or its members would seek political office, Gamal said.

Yet on Saturday, a member of al-Banna's Brotherhood will become Egypt's president. It's the most concrete example of how al-Banna's long-ago goal to save Islam from Western influences in his homeland came to define politics throughout the Arab world, engendering fear in the West and earning the Brotherhood the enmity of many Arab leaders.

The rise of Mohammed Morsi to the presidency is the story of the evolution of the Brotherhood, experts say, a tale of how a secret society with a history of violence - al-Banna was assassinated in 1949 - came to accept modern political compromise. One scholar of the Brotherhood called the group the Arab world's tea party: "dogmatic but politically practical."

The Brotherhood wants to apply Islamic law in a way that's different from what the United States understands it to be, said former member Kamal al-Helbawy. "It is freedom of expression, justice, shura (an Islamic advisory council) and human rights," said al-Helbawy, who left the Brotherhood last year after a 60-year membership because he disagreed with what he characterized as the furtive way the group now was governed.

"The Muslim Brotherhood wants to revive the Islamic civilization. ... We are trying to bring people back to the right approach of Islam that is based on the Islamic civilization," said Amr Darrag, a Brotherhood member of the 100-person assembly that's charged with writing Egypt's new constitution. "I know (Morsi) on a personal level. He has a strong character and he doesn't easily surrender. ... He is a very good choice for this period."


Al-Banna's group was one of many that popped up during the 1920s, when Egypt was liberal, occupied and itching for independence. But, as his elderly brother explained, in his office surrounded by books, al-Banna was the most organized of them all, a quality that defines the Brotherhood and allowed it to become Egypt's largest political organization within 20 years.

Hassan al-Banna welcomed anyone who wanted to join. Then he took his members, who represented every segment of society, and urged them to spread the message through their various unions, in media and in their communities.


Al-Banna believed that Egypt had lost its Islamic way and could fix its political situation only by changing the thinking of every Egyptian. That required members to integrate themselves into society and urge Egyptians to reconsider every aspect of their lives: education, Arab nationalism, development.

As Gamal recalled, his older brother despised politics. In a push for a simple life, his brother didn't own a car or have a bank account, Gamal said. But his organizational skills created a group that attracted power. And it empowered itself by providing social services to the less fortunate, earning their loyalty. From its earliest days until now, it sticks to message, a characteristic evident in Cairo's Tahrir Square, where supporters from throughout Egypt repeat the latest message from the Brotherhood verbatim.

"My brother once said, 'We don't want power, but power is seeking us,' " Gamal said. "He did not like politics, truly. But at the end of Hassan al-Banna's life it became the biggest organization in Egypt, so it had to be involved in politics."


Although many members weren't educated, the Brotherhood became a home for some Islamic scholars, who gave religious justification to the group's thinking.

"You need someone to issue the fatwas," said Ashraf el-Sherif, a Brotherhood expert at the American University in Cairo, describing what became known as the al-Azhar thread of the group, referring to the university in Cairo that's Sunni Islam's premier site of Islamic thought.


Violence wasn't a part of the group's early years, but the Brotherhood sent members to fight on behalf of the Palestinians in the war that led to the creation of Israel in 1949. That gave the Brotherhood a cadre of experienced fighters, and gave Egypt's leaders the fear that it could be plotting a coup.

Prime Minister Mahmoud Fahmi an-Nukrashi Pasha was the first of many Egyptian leaders to disband the group, and in 1948 a young Brotherhood member dressed as a police officer entered the Ministry of the Interior and assassinated him. A year later, al-Banna was shot to death while waiting for a cab after the government officials he was scheduled to meet with failed to show up. The site is now home to two spinoff Brotherhood organizations.

The 1952 revolution that ended the British presence in Egypt was a turning point in Brotherhood thought. Believing that the leader of that revolt, then-Col. Gamal Abdel Nasser, would embrace the Brotherhood's religion-based ideas, the Brotherhood worked with him to oust King Farouk and British imperialism.

But Nasser turned out to be more secular than the Brotherhood had expected. Once he became president, he began to monopolize power and arrest Brotherhood members. "The mistake of the Brotherhood was that they underestimated Nasser," American University's el-Sherif said. "They thought they were stronger."

In October 1954, a Brotherhood member attempted to assassinate Nasser, but the shots missed. Nasser retaliated with a massive crackdown that saw thousands of Brotherhood members arrested.

Among those who found themselves in jail was Sayed Qutb, whose writings in prison would reshape the Brotherhood.

Where al-Banna believed in slowly integrating into the existing order, Qutb believed in quickly creating a counter-society. It was secular, evil ideas introduced by British imperialism that threatened the Egyptian state, Qutb argued. The way to counter them was to create conservative communities, isolated from Western taint, he argued. His thinking took hold in part of the Brotherhood and would later become crucial to the philosophy of Osama bin Laden's al-Qaida.


Another strain of thought also was taking hold within the Brotherhood, and it was there that the group began to show its skill for political adaptability. It compromised, negotiated and worked with the existing secular state system.

"They wanted to stay out of jail," said Mohammed Abbas, a 30-something Brotherhood member until last year, when he started his own youth party.


By the 1970s, Qutbists shared power within the Brotherhood with a strain of so-called Salafists, conservative Islamists who were financed by donations from Saudi Arabia and other Persian Gulf nations where the oil boom was generating enormous wealth. Those donations paid for schools and media campaigns that introduced more conservative thinking on issues such as women and relations with Christians.

The Brotherhood renounced violence, but its seemingly conflicting message led to several violent offshoot groups such as al-Gamaa al-Islamaya, which the United States considered a terrorist organization. Members of yet another splinter group were responsible for the 1981 assassination of President Anwar Sadat after Sadat had signed a peace agreement with Israel.

It was during this period of ferment, in 1977, that Morsi joined the Brotherhood, while he was studying engineering in Los Angeles.

The period in which he joined continues to shape his thoughts today, according to el-Sherif. Morsi is both a religious conservative and a believer in moving quickly on reform.

"Morsi is a Salafist in how he understands faith but a Qutbist in how he understands organization," el-Sherif said.


By the 1990s, a new type of Brotherhood member had emerged, one who was more liberal than the organization itself. Abdel Moneim Aboul Fotouh, a onetime leading presidential contender, is a leader among this group. Such members embraced democracy and women's rights and revived the kind of gradual integration that al-Banna called for.

Which strain of the Brotherhood Morsi will represent isn't yet clear. He's shown himself to be a willing negotiator. In his first speech after his election was confirmed, he peppered Islamic references with a call for national unity. He issued a 16-point plan to be implemented in 100 days that began with instilling Islamic values and creating 700,000 jobs. Perhaps realizing the limitations of power, he later adjusted his timeline to "as soon as possible."


How he deals with Western influences is still to be seen. Many expect friction.

"The United States must now decide whether it will embrace a democratically elected Islamist or a secular dictator," al-Helbawy said.

However it turns out, Gamal al-Banna, 14 years younger than his brother and never a part of his brother's organization, is convinced of one thing: Morsi's election would please his brother.

Very simply, he said, his brother would embrace it because "it was God's will."

Courtesy: The Kansas City Star

Originally Posted on Fri, Jun. 29, 2012 04:28 PM

http://www.kansascity.com/2012/06/29/3683723/how-muslim-brotherhood-went-from.html

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Khelafat Good Governance as Perceived by the Mystic Bauls of Bangladesh

Selected Excerpts from Prof. Md.Amzad Hossain's "I am Harun Baul Speaking part-21"

[ http://baulism.blogspot.com/2012/04/im-harun-baul-speaking-part-21.html ]


তোমরা সব খলিফা র'লে, যে যা বুঝে দিও বলে।

অসৎ অভক্ত জনা, গুপ্ত ভেদ তারে বলো না

বলিলেও সে মানিবে না, করবে অহঙ্কারী।

নেকতন বান্দারা যত, বেদ পড়ে আউলিয়া হতো

নাদানেরা শুল চাছিতো, মনছুর তার সাবেদ আছে। (লালন ফকির)
-(Lalon Fakir)


(The Prophet (sm) instructed the Khalifas to advise the general people in accordance with their levels of understanding. The dishonest and non-devotees should not be told about the higher truth, for they are likely to reject it. All the righteous people can become Auliya (Godly) by understanding the higher truth while the fools are engaged in sharpening their spears. The case of Mansur (Hallaj) bears witness to it (whom they killed).


Guru Aziz Shah Fakir (104) relates the above notion of the Prophet Muhammad to his Khalifas in political terms of the Khelafat governance.

It clearly suggests that under the Khelafat system of good governance, the citizens should be dealt with in accordance with their level of understanding.

This wisdom is also equally applicable in the cases of dealing with economic and other needs of the people of a given time and place. Linking the concept to the case of present governance Bangladesh, the guru recognises a lack of good governance (Sushason) that persists at the heart of the present untenable situation in Bangladesh. He emphasises good governance as the jugular vein of a nation; and the practice of Khelafat’s good governance duly powered by the Islamic deliberative democracy can revitalize the sharply depleting happiness, traditional self-reliance, religiosity, patriotism, family and social bondage and eco-spirituality. The Khelafat system of governance is therefore a sustainable alternative that can transform Bangladesh to be (re)branded as the happiest nation on earth.


Bangladesh being predominantly a fertile land of population growth, agriculture and fisheries, it is a superior country for long-term sustainability. But unfortunately, the country has hardly experienced good governance that could potentially allow for political stability, and foster the human-nature interconnectedness through sustainable development. The guru stresses that the rising degradation of natural resources, water crisis, the widening gaps between the rich and poor, corruption, crimes and gender conflicts, are largely due to persisting mal-governance. The guru also stresses that politicians’ commitment to good governance has not been possible because it is integrally connected to people’s values system; and the current political as well as cultural values system of Bangladesh is at its worst. This values system is severely inflicted with selfishness and self-centricity that is intensely opposed to share things with fellow beings and care for natural resources. This disconnection of sharing and caring leads people to disengage themselves from their spiritual core of self-reliance and happiness.


Against this backdrop, the guru explores ways to restore just governance within the framework of the Khelafat system as was implemented by the Prophet Muhammad and the first four Khalifas of Islam (Abu Bakr, Omar, Osman and Ali). The guru asserts that the Khelafat system can create competent, honest, responsible and patriotic civil servants, activists and other actors. In this context, the guru adds that a Khalifa as a human representative or Vicegerent of God on earth can be a person of any colour, culture or religion, who, in congruence with the Quranic revelation, can coulour oneself with the colour of God. This means that a Khalifa has to acquire collective knowledge, lessons and wisdom for governance purposes and also for transmitting them to other people in order to maintain individual, familial, social, economic, religio-cultural, political and ecological sustainability. Then, how to acquire diverse knowledge for achieving Khalifaship (stewardship) integrity in order to keep natural system healthy for human sustainability? Most religions talk about acquiring diverse knowledge. The knowledge of nurturing nature and the realization of human’s absolute dependence on eco-resources intrinsically help acquire the wisdom for understanding the inner meaning humanity (i.e. know thyself). The notion of human as the Ashraful Mukhlukat (the best of creation) is embedded in this concept. ....

পাড়ে কে যাবি নবীর নৌকাতে আয়
রপ কাস্থের নৌকা খানি নাই ডুবার ভয়।
বেচারা নাইয়ে যারে
তুফানে যাবে মারা
এক ধাক্কায়।

(Ride on to the boat (Tarika) of the Prophet, if one who wishes to go across (the river of life). The boat is made of such a timber (virtues)) that has no fear of drowning. But those who are undisciplined boatman, they will ruin by a single blow).


The guru observes that Islamic original political culture as devised by the Prophet has hopelessly failed to demonstrate its ingeniousness over the global political culture, only due to the lack of maintaining the chain (Silsila) of succession after the fourth Khalifa Hazrat Ali. In fact, this deviation has eventually resulted in the downturn of Islamic governance worldwide; and currently, it has probably reached to its worst. However, the Sufi Islam that is still prominent in Bangladesh has the Tariqat (way) for safeguarding the politicians (Khalifas) who chose to embark on the Prophet’s and the four Khalifas’ Shariah of good governance. ....


The undisciplined politicians, religious bigots, ignorant pundits and egoistic civil servants who now own in the country’s governance are the Beshora Neye ( বে-শরা নাইয়া ) according Harun Baul’s sustainability assessment criteria. Consequently, the political culture in the land of Sufis which has been devoid of the spirit(uality) of Sufism, is justifiably failing to demonstrate the Banglalee cultural ingeniousness over the Western socio-political culture.


However, a new Nauka (boat) is to be built under the guidance of the Tarikat of the Sharia of Khelafat’s good governance system in order to carry out the following sustainability precepts and practices:


1. Practice of Religious and Cultural Values (ধর্ম ও সংস্কৃতির আমল)


Culture reflects the colour of a religion. Secularism of Sufi spirituality is prominent in Bangladesh and therefore communal conflict is almost non-existent. Khalafat governance will enrich the culture by wiping out the impurities generated by the Western democracy. Guru Aziz Shah Fakir has the code of life(style), religion and culture – the main aspects of human life. The following examples manifests guidelines for the aspects.


a. Satya bal su pathe chal, o re amar mon (সত্য বলো সুপথে চলো, ও রে আমার মন)


(O my mind, always tell the truth and remain on the 'Straight Path').


Guru Aziz Shah Fakir says that this is the seed ‘spell’ (mantra) for all religions.


b. The second mantra is:


মানুষ গুরু নিষিদ্ধ যার
সর্ব সাধন সিদ্ধ হয় তার।


Manush guru nishtha jar
Shorbo shadhon siddha hoy tar.


(All aspirations are fulfilled if endeavours for learning are guru-centric)


c. Thirdly:


আগে কি সুন্দর দিন কাটাইতাম
গ্রামের নওজোয়ান, হিন্দু মুসলমান
মিলিয়া বাউলের গান আর মুর্শিদী গাইতাম (বাউল আব্দুল করিম শাহ)
Baul Abdul Karim shah

(What a delightful time we had in the past. The village youths from the Hindu and Muslim communities used to sing Baul and Mushidi songs together).


There are hundreds of examples in this context that are practical in nature. Whatever we learn needs to be practiced. The Sufi culture requires the Khalifa to ‘learn from the people who know’ and follow the path and doings of the blessed people who are known as the Aulyia or friends of God. Teachings of a wise master or a Khalifa – formally or otherwise – is primarily to teach people how to practice charity, modesty, live simply, honesty, truthfulness, tolerance, respectfulness, trustworthiness, responsibility, discipline, sociality, care taking and nature nurturing. These values can cause to vanish growing corruption, cheating, bestiality and lawlessness as water can extinguish water. The legal framework of the Khelafat governance is to implement the moral principles so that people’s mindset becomes values-driven. The corrective measures are to be provided in order to treat the odds.


2. Fish and tree for everyone (সবার জন্য মাছ ও গাছ)


Everyone needs fish and fruit trees. This is achievable should the Ward Khalifas know how to initiate and implement fishing and plantation programs in their respective area. To avail fish and fruits for everyone, watersheds need to be maintained so that they are deep enough to hold knee-level water in the summer as a poem reads:


আমাদের ছোট নদী চলে বাঁকে বাঁকে,
বৈশাখ মাসে তার হাটু জল থাকে।


(ameder soto nodi chole babnke banke;
boishakh mashe tar hatu jol thake)


Fishing, especially the immature, fingerlings and mother fish with eggs must be stopped seasonally, and fish export can be allowed only after meeting the local people’s needs. Plantation for regeneration and restoration of fruit trees in abundance must be done throughout the banks of watersheds and roadside including some timber trees, cane, bamboos and medicinal plants and herbs on the roadsides. If this is implemented, it will not only help avail fruits and meet household needs for those who have no place to grow, but also meet the needs of the present and future healing of illness, it will also ensure environmental sustainability. Perceiving this, Baul Bijoy Sarkar reveals:


ঐ পৃথিবী যেমন ছিলো, তেমনি ঠিক রবে
সুন্দর ঐ পৃথিবী ছেড়ে চলে যেতে হবে।


Ai prithibi jemon silo, Temoni thik robe
Sundar ai prithibi sere chole jete hobe.


(We are obliged to leave this beautiful earth, keeping the earth in its natural form). The song implies that one generation should leave this beautiful earth aesthetically and eco-systematically unchanged for meeting the needs of the generations to come; and next generation will be obliged to follow their ancestor’s tradition. This notion is also the core of the concept of sustainable development.


3. Full support for the people willing to work overseas (কাজের জন্য বিদেশ যাত্রীদেরকে টাকা ধার)


Almost every family with workable manpower wants to send a family member overseas. The Ward Khalifas can implement this national project giving financial support from the Khalifa’s local development fund to those who are in need. Producing exportable workforce with values, quality and skill is the holy responsibility of the Khalifas. This responsibility will inspire the Ward Khalifas and the candidates (present and future) to introduce adequate logistical support for the same).


4. Facilities for small-scale industrial productivity (ক্ষুদ্র ও কুটির শিল্পের অবাধ বিস্তার)


This will help families needing extra income. The Khelafat system of governance can launch a revolutionary industrial transformation process towards achieving economic self-reliance as Gandhi propagated. The households can spin, weave and make their own dresses and sell to others. Cotton, jute, silk, wool and other local fibers can be used. This provision can employ a huge amount of workforce including women, children, and the aged. The Khelafat governance can introduce a policy that the country’s local needs for garments are to be wholly produced locally.


5. To narrow down the lifestyle gaps between rich and poor (ধনি দরিদ্রের জীবন যাত্রা মানের বৈষম্য কমান)


This can be achieved through a national policy which can motivate the rich or elite class to come closer to the poor in their dress and food habit; addressing poor with respect; and sharing each other’s joy and sorrow. A national policy with wide manifestation of better-off people’s brotherhood/sisterhood mannerism to the ordinary folks (sub-ordinates, employees, servants, labourers); a habit of sharing food, dress, affordable money, and joy and sorrow with the have-nots; the well-offs' visit to poor neighbourhood and hospitals; modest and simple lifestyle in terms of dress - all these will automatically bring down poverty situation both materially and psychologically. Harun Baul asserts that alleviation of poverty is neither possible in the geo-environmental and cultural conditions of Bangladesh, nor it is at all desirable for the sake of a long-term sustainability of the renewable resources of the county. Thus, a poverty-like modest lifestyle is the sustainable direction for Bangladesh. And this applies also for the global sustainability.


6. Self-reliance centric foreign policy (স্বনির্ভরকেন্দ্রিক বৈদেশিক নীতি)


Diplomatic relationship with foreign countries needs to be central to earning foreign currency to assist our self-reliant sustainability in terms of cotton, oil, chemicals, minerals, etc that our country currently lacks. We have exportable manpower and garments as the means to earning foreign currency. In the wake of declining population growth in the so-called developed countries where the primary schools suffer from the scarcity of the starters and industries are closed down because of the shortage of labour force, it is clear that the present rate of population growth is sustainable if they are properly educated and trained for employment or migration overseas.


Finally, the guru is also concerned about the number of ministries. For a country like Bangladesh where the prevalence of immorality such as corruption, cheating, exploitation, extortion, lawlessness and bestiality is rampant, it is essential that the existing numerous ministries be integrated into a few Apex Ministries; and they are to be controlled by lowly paid or Honorary Executive Khalifas.


In conclusion, Harun Baul suggests that it is crucial for the pro-Khelafat parties ...to start their work at the grassroots level to find competent Khalifas at the Ward, Union and Thana level. They should also seek support from the Non-Resident Bangladeshi (NRB) for outlining working papers for triggering the Khelafat system of deliberative democratic governance.


(To be continued)

Dated 24-04-2012 www.bangladesh-web.com

Md. Amzad Hossain
a.hossain@curtin.edu.au